Plenty of Fish has been around forever in dating app years. But not everyone loves it. Some find it too basic, others feel it’s overcomplicated, and many just want something different. That’s why there are more singles who are looking for sites like POF! So we tested all the popular POF alternative platforms to recommend the best.
So, if you are looking for casual fun, something discreet, or just want something better than POF, here are the sites that made the cut:
We get that it’s not easy to choose among the best hookup dating sites. But we got more in-depth reviews ready for you, so you can learn and see what fits your vibe better.
If POF feels too slow, OneNight Friend is the opposite. It’s designed for fast, flirty connections without the long bios and endless messaging.
Sign-up is quick, the interface is clean, and the search filters make it easy to find singles who want the same thing as you do. This Plenty of Fish alternative has very appealing profiles, as its users are not shy about their desires.
Messaging is a premium feature, which means the people who reach out are serious about meeting. That helps avoid users who are “just browsing.” OneNight Friend runs on subscriptions that range from $0.99 for 1 day to $79.99 for 3 months.
OneNight Friend is not trying to be similar to Plenty of Fish, where relationships tend to take months to get to that date. It’s more about immediate spark and chemistry, and fun plans. It is one of the good POF alternatives for singles who want to skip the slow burn and jump into sexting right away.
While there are many good local dating apps for men, some sites match you with someone hot…but across the world. A good sexting session never hurts, but sometimes you want someone nearby to have fun with. That’s one of the common reasons people are looking for apps like POF. And TopLocalSingles is just the place for matching with nearby hookups!
You don’t browse profiles from the other side of the country, but see people within the radius you choose. It’s perfect for last-minute drinks or casual dates without the headaches of long distance.
TopLocalSingles is one of the sites like Plenty of Fish that provides convenient search filters. Creating a profile takes just minutes. Free users can browse profiles and see all the public photos and info, but messaging and advanced features require a premium (extras cost $2.99 for three messages).
This one’s not just for hookups, as you’ll find people who want something more, too. But most members are seeking easy hookups. So, if you want something similar to POF but that is specialized in local, TopLocalSingles is worth trying.
When you think about apps like Plenty of Fish, you might picture small niche sites. But AdultFriendFinder is everything but that. It’s huge and you’ll like it.
AFF has existed since 1996 and has over 70 million registered users as of 2025. It’s one of the largest casual dating platforms and is great for NSA arrangements, open-minded relationships, and living out one’s kinks and fetishes.
This place may feel more like a social network, as its community is very active. Also, all the group chat features, forums, comments, and discussions add to that feeling. You can join chat rooms, watch streams, and connect in themed groups, which makes it easy to find your crowd.
The design of AdultFriendFinder looks a bit old-school, but all the features and services work well. You can search by location preferences and even kinks. But keep in mind that some services are available only for premium members, and the cost of AFF premium starts at $14.95 per month.
If you are looking for Plenty of Fish alternatives to get a better variety and community, AFF is a top contender. It’s hard to find something better among the casual platforms than this.
That’s not a straight alternative among the websites like POF, as Ashley Madison is a bit about another type of dating. The site is known for privacy and discreet arrangements. But even though it was initially made for just affairs, it’s now a top spot for all sorts of casual fun.
Ashley Madison’s profiles are more detailed than on other websites like Plenty of Fish, which helps to find the right match. It’s cool that you can blur your photos, control who sees your profile, and stay as private as you like.
The community on Ashley Madison understands boundaries, and there’s also no judgment. You can feel free to have the relationship you want. Moreover, you meet many people who are looking for the same thing.
Ashley Madison is not a universal alternative to POF, but it’s one of the cool ones that can make you drool over the spicy hidden albums. But it’s not free. Ashley Madison offers free membership, yet communication and most advanced features require credits or a subscription. The cost of credits starts at $69 for 100 credits, and premium memberships start at $32.99 per month.
This site like POF has a name that speaks for itself. And it’s exactly what it sounds like – flirty and fun. The site offers quick sign-up, so you can start browsing immediately. BeNaughty’s profiles are usually bold with cheeky bios and photos you’ll drool a little over. The search filters are there to help you find potential hookups by location and your preferences.
The free version is fine, and you can get limited fun, but upgrading gets you unlimited messaging, photo viewing, and other advanced features. BeNaughty runs on subscriptions and offers a 3-day trial membership for just $2.99.
BeNaughty is an alternative to POF that is worth your time because of its pace. You start chatting fast, and members are not shy about what they want. That saves a lot of time on search and allows you to enjoy more time offline than online. If POF feels too slow for you or too “serious,” BeNaughty ditches the formality, and you’ll like it.
POF works for some, but many singles eventually start looking for sites similar to Plenty of Fish for different reasons. Here are the most common reasons why:
All in all, POF may still work for some, but there are many alternatives that are better, and you’ll regret not trying them.
Modern dating is about finding what fits your lifestyle. If you feel that POF is not doing it for you, it’s okay to find a change. We offered the best sites like POF so that you have enough room to check out and try out. All of them are a bit different, and the right choice for you depends only on what you want, as we have already tested the quality.
